I am finally getting around to reviewing some desserts at a restaurant I like (or maybe used to like) in Providence. The restaurant is Big Fish and it's in the Jewelry District in an old mechanic's garage. So, the front room has glass garage doors, which looks very cool. Also, when you walk in, there is an entry way that makes you feel like you are inside a waterfall and cool fish doorknobs on the inside door. I really do like the atmosphere in there. Also, when the weather is nice, there is a Tiki Bar outside. Who doesn't like a Tiki Bar?
Anyway, last night was the fourth time I've been to Big Fish. I loved it so much the first two times, I've gone back. They claim to support local fisherman and sustainable means of gathering fish. So, there's an added bonus.
I'll get to the desserts in a second, but would first like to mention the fun drink list. Last night, I had a Great White, which was essentially a Cosmo with white cranberry juice. Now, any drink that comes with a toy shark attached sounds awesome to me. I think it would have tasted better if I hadn't gotten a rookie bartender who didn't really know how to make the drink. There was a bit too much Triple Sec in it. Nevertheless, we all had fun playing with the shark, which is now sitting on top of a shelf in my living room.
I'll just briefly mention the food, just as an FYI. The food was stellar the first two times I went. Both times, I had cod with the most amazing bacon-sherry-shitake sauce and arugala. Really, it was amazing. The people with whom I went also had great drinks and great meals. We never did get dessert, though.
However, their dessert menu is the coolest idea ever. They have about 6 standard desserts that they have photographed and put onto View Master slides. By View Master, I mean those little plastic toys we all had back in the 1970s that had those small round wheels of photos. You'd look through the View Master and click it to advance the slides. The slides would be in themes, like National Parks, Snakes and Lizards, Huckleberry Hound, etc. You know what I'm talking about.
So, there you are, ready to see a dessert menu and out comes one of those View Masters. I don't care how old you are, the kid in you comes out. And, visually, seeing those desserts makes you want one even if you're full! Man, that is such a good idea.
Now, the last time I went, I thought the food was just OK. It wasn't bad. But, it just didn't WOW me, like the first two times. I did share a dessert, though. I can't remember the catchy names they use for everything, but it was a cotton candy creme brulee (literally a creme brulee wrapped in blue cotton candy). It sounds gross, but really was interesting coupled together. The creme brulee that night was done right, too, so it was delicious.
Now, last night, we ordered five desserts: Twinkie Tiramisu, Triple Chocolate Mousse, one of those cotton candy creme brulees, a S'mores brownie, and chocolate bread pudding. I tasted everything. And, I was so sad that nothing really lived up to those awesome pictures on the View Master. Then, I felt that maybe I shouldn't do reviews on my website if all I'm going to do is judge and complain. I mean, who I am to critique this stuff. But, hey, even someone who isn't in culinary school could tell that the brownie was way over baked, it was difficult or near impossible to taste the mascarpone cheese or liquor in the tiramisu (it really just tasted like a Twinkie with chantilly on top), the triple chocolate mousse didn't have the consistency of mousse at all and seemed like cocoa flavored whipped cream, and, well, all the chantilly on the desserts was way way over whipped (and curdling). The bread pudding, however, was good. Not great, but good. It had a rich flavor and was baked to a proper consistency. We were pretty happy about that.
The waiter, a very friendly guy who I've had before, did ask us what we thought. So, we were honest. And, I mentioned I really did notice a difference between the first two meals and the last two meals I've had there. I even filled out a suggestion card. It seems they've cleaned house, which, quite frankly, makes sense. It just wasn't the same.
Big Fish has great ideas and tons of potential on that dessert menu. They just have to refine and finesse things a bit and execute the final product correctly so the quality matches those fantastic images on the View Master. I'm not going to give up on them yet.